Open Accessibility Menu
Your health and safety are our highest priority during this time. Click here for our precautionary measures.

Siding Repair vs New Installation: Which Is Right for You?

You can give your home a facelift by updating the siding. However, it can prove tricky deciding between siding repair vs new installation.

Maintaining your siding is an important part of caring for your home. By taking care of important features, such as your siding, you can prevent severe structural damage, save money, and keep your home looking sharp.

Along with annual checks and maintenance, you should keep an eye on your siding. If you’re vigilant about maintaining the exterior of your home, you’ll know when to replace siding.

Every season, you should check to make sure that your siding is in good condition, just as you check your heater in the fall. If you see a problem that’s beyond your ability, then it’s time to make an appointment with a contractor to fix the problem.

To find out more about siding repair vs installation, continue reading.

Know the Signs of Siding Trouble

The siding on your home makes a statement. It’s a testament to your character and your sense of style. Also, your siding protects the internal structure of your residence.

Antiquated or damaged siding is more than unattractive. It can reduce the value of your home.

Damaged siding is also a weakness in the barrier that protects the frame of your house. It can lead to moisture, which can, in turn, rot the beams that hold up your walls.

If there is extensive damage, or you’ve let damage go unchecked for some time, a small repair is most likely out of the question. Furthermore, your siding may have suffered damage from pests such as termites if you haven’t checked it in some time. Weather, cracks, fading, and peeling are all enemies of wood siding.

Fading is another big problem. The sun’s persistent rays can cause siding to fade over time. A continuous cycle of freezing and thawing can cause siding to become misshapen.

Wood isn’t the only siding material that’s prone to warping and swelling. Moisture can also cause damage in steel siding in the form of rust.

Sometimes, your siding will have damage, but it will still look great. However, you may experience mold growth on the inside of your home. This mold may have presented in your home because there’s a crack or a leak in your siding.

Interior mold is a sign of a much bigger problem. If you ever see mold in your home, you should contact a contractor right away to resolve the issue.

Making Choices: Siding Repair or Replacement?

If your siding is old-fashioned, you may want to consider updating the exterior of your home with new materials. An update will add curb appeal to your home, increase its value, and lower your utility bills.

Modern siding materials require much less maintenance. Also, they’re more attractive and better insulated compared to their predecessors. Accordingly, it makes sense to replace rather than repair old siding.

Alternatively, you may decide to replace only sections of your siding. However, there’s a big drawback to this plan.

It’s nearly impossible to get new siding to match the old siding, so the repair work is painfully obvious. A new section will look brighter than the rest of your home.

Some contractors excel at matching colors to existing siding. Still, it’s highly improbable that even an expert can make new siding match old materials perfectly. The only way to overcome this obstacle is to paint the entire house after the repair.

It helps to think of new siding as an investment. Usually, homeowners recover most – if not all – of their investment in new siding.

New siding is one of the top ways you can invest in your home to improve its value. Typically, homeowners recover over 100% of remodeling costs when choosing to replace the exterior of their homes.

Best of all, fresh siding can make your entire home look brand-new. With new siding, you can say goodbye to your home’s “That 70s Show” look and step into the architectural realm of a “Modern Family.”

In addition to recouping your investment by increasing your home’s value, energy-efficient, modern siding can also help you enjoy annual savings. Throughout the year, updated siding can reduce the cost required to cool your home in the summer and heat it in the winter.

Dealing with Uninvited Guests

Several common issues may warrant siding repair vs replacement. For instance, wood siding is especially susceptible to pests.

Enemies of wood siding can range from woodpeckers to termites and carpenter bees. As nature’s beloved creatures scavenge for a meal or look for a home, they’ll tunnel through the wood. As these buggers do what they were born to do, they’ll compromise the integrity of your siding.

The holes that animals and insects leave behind in siding expose the structure of your home to the elements. As a result, an infestation of any kind can cause the framework of your home to rot. In a worst-case scenario, a home overrun by an animal or insect incursion can collapse.

You can prevent insect damage with pesticides. If only a small area of your siding is damaged, you can have a contractor repair the area and spray pesticides to keep away bugs. There are also eco-friendly products that you can have a contractor use on the foliage surrounding your house that will keep wood-eating offenders away.

Moisture is another serious issue with failed siding. The worst moisture damage, however, happens when you can’t see a breach in your siding. Usually, you won’t notice this type of damage until your siding starts to warp or buckle.

Lax maintenance can allow these kinds of small problems to become big issues. Small problems begin with old paint peeling from the siding. In time, this kind of breach can become something worse.

Today, many manufacturers market their siding material as low maintenance. However, that doesn’t mean that you can install it and forget about it.

Even the best siding left unattended will fail given enough time. By scheduling a regular maintenance check, your local contractor can catch small problems before they become major repairs.

The Case for Replacing Your Siding

The beauty of wood siding is undeniable. However, vinyl siding is typically a more reasonable option for most of today’s homeowners.

Vinyl siding requires much less upkeep compared to wood. You don’t have to paint it. Most often, the only thing you need to do is wash it with a hose occasionally.

This low maintenance benefit is usually a top consideration when homeowners ask themselves, “Should I repair or replace my siding?” The idea of not having to care for wood siding is often hard to resist.

However, vinyl siding also has its weaknesses. In some ways, vinyl is fragile.

Impacts and extreme temperatures can cause vinyl to crack. When this happens, it’s best to replace the damaged areas immediately.

Some homeowners, however, can’t resist the allure of wood or cedar siding, and that’s fine. However, there are common issues with this type of exterior material.

Wood Siding Is Attractive but Prone to Damage

Wood siding is subject to gouges. For example, heavy hail can leave deep marks in cedar and wood siding.

Typically, you can repair damage to wood siding by sanding it and applying a fresh coat of paint to the area. You may also have to fill in the gash with outdoor spackle. Again, any such spot repair is likely to leave signs of its presence, disrupting the continuity of your home and diminishing its appearance.

Dampness is also an enemy of wood siding. Enough moisture can cause wood to decay.

You can repair or replace damaged siding. In some instances, you only need to replace a few shingles or boards. In other cases, however, you’ll need to replace the whole wall.

When siding becomes rotted or cracked beyond repair, replacement is unavoidable. You can do these kinds of repairs yourself. However, a contractor’s work will almost always look better.

You can avoid most of these kinds of problems with annual maintenance. By caring for your siding, you can extend the life cycle of your exterior and your home.

Siding Choices: Know Your Options

Over the years, manufacturers have tried to introduce different siding materials to the housing market. However, a few siding materials have stood the test of time.

When considering new siding, most homeowners love the appearance of wood. However, that passion fades once they realize the maintenance involved with maintaining a wood exterior. Still, there are many beautiful styles, textures, and finishes of wood siding on the market, and that most likely won’t change in the foreseeable future.

At some point, manufacturers introduced metal siding to overcome the drawbacks of wood covering materials. For example, aluminum siding is a low maintenance alternative compared to wood.

Recently, however, the falling cost of steel has sparked interest among homeowners in using the metal for siding. Manufacturers also make aluminum and steel siding and horizontal strips that resemble wood.

Metal siding is available in a variety of styles, including vertical and horizontal panels. It’s also available in shingles.

Usually, manufacturers will coat metal siding with a corrosive-resistant, colored finish. You can also purchase unfinished metal siding that’s galvanized to protect against corrosion.

For now, vinyl siding is the low cost, low maintenance top choice of most homeowners. Typically, manufacturers make siding in strips with interlocking edges.

Vinyl siding is available in a range of styles, including vertical and horizontal panels. It’s also available in many colors. With vinyl siding, homeowners can choose their favorite color and never have to worry about painting.

For homeowners who love the look of wood, vinyl doesn’t disappoint. Manufacturers make vinyl siding that looks like wood shakes and shingles.

As with any new siding installation, the quality of a contractor’s work makes all the difference in the world. If a contractor installs vinyl incorrectly, it’s likely to warp or buckle.

Only the Best for Your Home

If you’re vigilant in maintaining your siding, it can last for around five decades with little maintenance. More importantly, it will protect your home from insects and moisture. For now, vinyl is the most affordable and popular siding choice among homeowners.

Hands down, vinyl is the winner when it comes to maintenance and durability. Furthermore, there is a seemingly endless selection of colors and styles for the building material.

You’ll never mistake vinyl siding for wood. However, manufacturers are getting better at making vinyl siding that mimics wood materials.

The biggest weakness of vinyl is fading. You can purchase colorfast siding, but you’ll pay for it.

There are other advanced features that you can choose for your vinyl siding. For instance, you can buy vinyl siding with fewer seams. Fewer seams will create a more unified look around your home. These panels are usually 12 to 13 feet long.

You can also choose vinyl siding with a double hem. This kind of siding attaches more securely to the wall.

You can also choose vinyl siding with foam backing. Foam backing provides more insulation, cutting down on heating and cooling costs.

There’s also extra durable siding that’s resistant to intense climates. This kind of siding is extra rigid and lies flatter and straighter. As a result, it’s more wind resistant than standard siding.

Finding a Great Contractor for New Siding

New siding is only as good as its installer. Choosing the right contractor is just as important as choosing the right siding.

To find a great contractor, do some research on the Better Business Bureau website. Also, ask for references from your friends and family members about their experiences with local siding contractors.

Finally, talk to more than one contractor. You should get a minimum of two to three quotes before you decide on a service provider.

Trust Experts to Care for Your Most Important Investment

Mr. Handyman contractors have the tools and expertise to perform perfect siding repair or new siding installation for your Keller, Flower Mound, or Alliance, TX home. When you want a better final result, our experts are up to the task.

Contact us today to get started on your project and give your home a fresh look with new siding!